10 Best Substitutes for Mustard Seeds for Your Recipes

Substitutes for Mustard Seeds for your recipes
15 min reading time

Mustard seed has been a popular spice for centuries, adding delicious flavor to dishes. From Indian curries to spicy Dijon mustards, it’s clear that this tiny but mighty spice plays an important role in adding flavor to our favorite meals. But what do you do if you’re out of mustard seed? Can other ingredients take their place? Absolutely!

In this blog post, we’ll explore 10 excellent substitutes for mustard seeds that you can use in a pinch when your recipe calls for it, so read on to find out more and never get caught without the right seasoning again!

What are Mustard Seeds?

Mustard seeds are the small round seeds of various mustard plants. They are also sometimes referred to as white mustard, black mustard, and brown mustard depending on their color.

Mustard is one of the oldest known condiments and has been used for millennia in various cuisines across the world. In India, it is believed that bringing a bag of mustard seeds into your home will invite prosperity and wealth. In China, it was often used medicinally to treat bronchitis and other chest ailments.

The scientific name for the plant from which mustard comes is Brassica juncea or Sinapis alba (white/yellow).” When crushed or ground, these tiny seeds become an important ingredient in many condiments such as Dijon-style mustards, stoneground mustards, and yellow ballpark hot dogs mustards. The potent acidity associated with mustard is derived primarily from two natural compounds: sinigrin (allyl glucosinolate) — responsible for giving it its robust kick — and allylisothiocyanate (a volatile oil found within the cells of the mustards).

In Ayurvedic medicine (an ancient Indian system of healing), black mustard seed was traditionally believed to hold numerous health benefits.

What do Mustard Seeds Taste Like?

Mustard seeds have a fiery, spicy taste that is often likened to wasabi. When you bite into a raw mustard seed, the first thing you will notice will be its strong pungency – some find it extremely hot while others just detect warmth. The flavor has been compared to horseradish and wasabi due to their similarities in taste profiles – each has an unmistakable spiciness with a slight bitterness lingering at the back of your palate.

However, once cooked or processed further (such as being soaked overnight), they become mellow and nutty – like eating roasted sunflower seeds! Roasting them on low heat before grinding will bring out more subtle notes of sweetness too such as honey or maple syrup!

What are The Different Types of Mustard Seed?

The mustard plant yields three very distinct types of seeds: black, brown, and white.

  • Black Mustard Seeds: Black mustard has a strong flavor and aroma when cooked; its pungency intensifies with heat. It goes well with curries, pickles, and chutneys as both an aromatic spice and a thickener for sauces or gravies.
  • Brown Mustard Seeds: This variety is quite mild compared to the black seed but still has a pleasant piquancy when heated that is excellent for tempering vegetables like cauliflower, eggplant, or potatoes or adding flavor to soups, stews, and dals (Indian lentil-based dishes).
  • White Mustard Seeds: White mustard is less harsh than either black or brown varieties but still provides some subtle zest to hot dishes like stir fries, roasted veggies, salad dressings, and pasta dishes.

10 Best Substitutes for Mustard Seeds You Should Try

When it comes to cooking, trying new ingredients is part and parcel of the journey. Sometimes substitutions are made because of dietary or personal preferences, or quite simply because we have run out of an ingredient. If you are in search of substitutes for mustard seeds, there are a few options to explore.

Let’s learn about different substitutes for the mustard seeds that are available;

1. Horseradish

Horseradish root and grated horseradish

Horseradish is a popular condiment made from the root of a plant in the Brassica family, closely related to the mustard seed. It can be used as an alternative to a mustard seed in many dishes for its unique tangy flavor and crunchy texture. Horseradish can also be added to sandwiches, salad dressing, and other sauces for additional flavor.

When using horseradish as a substitute for mustard seed, keep in mind that it has a much stronger taste than traditional mustard which may overpower some delicate flavors. For this reason, you’ll want to use smaller quantities — about half what you would normally use if using mustard seed — when adding horseradish to your dish.

Using prepared horseradish will bring out its best aroma; however, if you are feeling adventurous and have access to fresh-grated horseradish root then go ahead! The fresher the better! Grating your own will provide more intense flavors without losing any nutritional value due to long-term exposure to air or light. Its oils remain locked inside until they come into contact with moisture from saliva during chewing

2. Wasabi

Wasabi (Japanese horseradish)

Wasabi, also known as Japanese horseradish, is becoming an increasingly popular substitute for mustard seed due to its unique and bold flavor. Wasabi has a distinctively strong and spicy taste that pairs well with the milder flavors of fish dishes like sushi or sashimi. Additionally, its bright green color adds a distinctive visual component to many recipes.

One of the main reasons why wasabi is such an effective substitute for mustard seeds is that it contains many of the same bioactive compounds found in mustard seeds. For instance, both contain pungent compounds called sinigrin and allyl isothiocyanate (AITC), which are responsible for their spicy flavors but can also offer health benefits such as anti-inflammatory effects and regulating blood sugar levels.

Moreover, unlike conventional yellow mustards which consist mainly of ground seed mixtures combined with vinegar and/or other acidic ingredients between two and three percent by weight (2-3%), wasabi consists primarily of pure essential oils extracted from freshly grated horseradish root without additives or preservatives – making it naturally gluten-free!

3. Caraway Seeds

Caraway seeds used as one of the substitutes for mustard seeds

Caraway seeds are an excellent source of fiber, minerals, and vitamins and are known for their high content of essential fatty acids. They also contain compounds such as carvone and limonene that provide unique therapeutic benefits. Additionally, caraway is useful as a digestive aid because it helps stimulate appetite and digestion.

The distinct taste of caraway seeds comes from its combination of the bitter-tasting compound carvone with sweet undertones produced by limonene. This makes it an ideal replacement for mustard seed in many recipes that use either flavor profile—from savory dishes like curries to sweeter treats like cakes or cookies! Caraway also has a mild licorice flavor which combines nicely with other herbs in salads or relishes too!

Mustard seeds are rich sources of phytonutrients like selenium and magnesium, but they can also be quite hot when eaten raw or cooked improperly. In contrast, caraway’s milder flavor ensures that its inherent health benefits remain intact even after cooking without imparting any bitterness or heat.

4. Turmeric

powdered turmeric in a bowl

Turmeric is a popular spice that has been used in traditional medicines all over the world for centuries. This orange-yellow root contains powerful phytochemicals which have been found to have many beneficial health properties. It should come as no surprise then, that turmeric is increasingly being used as a substitute for mustard seed – an ingredient which can often be challenging to source and difficult to process.

The main reason turmeric makes an excellent substitution for mustard seed is its naturally high content of curcuminoids – compounds responsible for giving this spice its distinctive yellow color and flavor. Curcuminoids are known to act as antioxidants, helping protect us from inflammation, oxidative stress, and even some types of cancer. They have also been found to possess anti-bacterial and anti-fungal properties making them ideal candidates when it comes to treating certain infections or symptoms related to digestive health issues like irritable bowel syndrome (IBS).

Moreover, while mustard seeds contain relatively low amounts of essential vitamins and minerals, one teaspoon of ground turmeric provides around 26% daily value (DV) of manganese in addition to 6% DV of iron; not forgetting significant amounts of dietary fiber, vitamin B6 plus trace amounts other necessary nutrients like potassium, magnesium calcium & zinc just make using turmeric more attractive.

5. Prepared Mustard

mustard sauce in a bowl

Prepared mustard, also known as “mustard sauce,” is a great substitute for mustard seed in recipes like vinaigrettes and marinades. Unlike the pungent, spicy flavor of mustard seed, prepared mustard has been predigested to serve up a milder version of its distinctive taste.

The beauty of prepared mustard lies in its makeup: It’s made with ground yellow or brown (or both) seeds that are heated and then mixed with vinegar and other ingredients such as turmeric, garlic powder, and sugar to give it zing. Some varieties have horseradish or even honey added. Mustard is packed with vitamins A and C which help improve skin tone, hair growth, digestion, vision health, and cell repair.

When substituting prepared mustards in place of the whole seed variety for non-cooking uses (like making condiments or sauces), be sure to check the label—some companies will add filler ingredients like flour or cornstarch which can affect the final product’s texture significantly. To get optimal flavor when cooking with prepared mustards instead of whole seeds – you’ll want to add more than you would usually use; since most mustards lose their heat when cooked.

6. Cumin

cumin seeds on a wooden spoon

Cumin is a spice that has been used in cooking for thousands of years and it is known to have great health benefits too. It has an earthy, nutty flavor and aroma with warm, slightly pungent notes. The powder form of cumin is frequently added to dishes such as curries, stews, soups, and sauces.

As a substitute for mustard seed, cumin does not provide the same pungency or bitterness but it still carries flavors that pair well with meats, vegetables, rice dishes, and lentils. When substituting for mustard seed in recipes where crunchiness matters (like salads or pickles), try using roasted cumin seeds instead of the ground powder form since they will retain their crunch after being cooked longer than other forms such as ground powder or oil-roasted flakes.

It also offers some health benefits which include: aiding digestion; controlling cholesterol levels; providing relief from respiratory disorders; boosting immunity; fighting disease-causing bacteria and viruses due to its antimicrobial properties; reducing risk factors linked with diabetes by regulating blood sugar levels due to its hypoglycemic effects among others.

7. Mayonnaise

mayonnaise sauce used as one of the substitutes for mustard seed

Mustard seed and mayonnaise are two different ingredients, but they both have similar effects in many dishes. Substituting mayonnaise for mustard seeds can be a great way to flavor your favorite recipes without having to buy mustard seeds specifically.

When using mayonnaise as a substitute for mustard seed, you will want to use approximately one tablespoon of mayo per teaspoon of mustard seed that the recipe calls for. The exact amount can vary depending on the type of recipe you’re making and how much of a kick you want from the substitution. You should also keep in mind that milder-tasting mayo usually has less fat than standard, which means it won’t provide quite as much flavor as regular or spicy-style versions.

Mayonnaise can be used to replace mustard in almost any recipe, including potato salads, sandwiches, vinaigrettes, and dressings as well as marinades. In addition to providing subtle flavor, switching out traditional yellow mustards with creamy mayos helps bring new textures into play – something which can really change up how dishes look and feel when served!

8. Ground Mustard Powder

mustard powder in a glass jar

Ground mustard, which is also known as dry mustard, or powdered mustard, is a spice used as a substitute for Mustard Seed in some recipes. Ground mustard powder is made by grinding up dried mustard seeds into a fine powder to create its intense flavor profile with a less spicy kick compared to using whole or cracked seeds. The different varieties of ground mustard powders on the market are typically categorized into two types: white (or yellow) and black (or brown).

One of the main differences between ground mustard and whole seed lies in their texture and flavor; while both have pungent taste profiles, ground mustard has a finer powdery consistency that’s easily dispersed in liquid-based foods. Additionally, ground mustard contains much more robust flavor notes compared with its seed counterpart.

Therefore if you’re looking for heat that lingers on your tongue then it may be worth considering finishing off your dish with an additional teaspoon of ground mustard instead of seeds – this will add depth without compromising on texture.

9. German Mustard

german mustard seeds used as one of the substitutes for mustard seed
Source: www.thespruceeats.com

German mustard, or Senff, is a popular condiment in Germany. It’s made from the same yellow mustard seeds used to make other types of mustard, but it has an added twist thanks to the addition of vinegar and spices. This gives it a unique flavor and texture that sets it apart from regular American-style mustards.

For those who want something different than plain yellow mustard, German mustard can be a great substitute for traditional mustards like Dijon or stone ground varieties. The basic ingredients in most German mustards are white wine vinegar, sugar, salt (usually sea salt), water, and then either prepared yellow or brown mustard seeds. Depending on the brand you buy (or if you choose to make your own) additional spices such as allspice, nutmeg, and cloves might be added as well.

The flavor of German Mustard can range from mild to spicy depending on the brand and ingredients used; however, its texture tends to be more coarse than typical American-style yellow mustard which makes it ideal as an accompaniment for sandwiches rather than smooth sauces/dressings like ranch dressing or Thousand Island Dressing where regular American-style mustards would fit better.

10. Chinese Mustard

Chinese mustard is a great substitute for regular mustard seed in many of the same ways. In fact, this type of mustard has some additional benefits as well. Chinese Mustard is a traditional condiment used in Chinese cooking and can vary in flavor depending on its preparation. It usually has a sweet and spicy flavor that adds an extra sparkle to many dishes, which makes it ideal as a replacement for regular mustard seeds which can be bland.

Compared to other mustards such as dijon or stoneground varieties, Chinese Mustard carries a bolder flavor because it contains additional spices like garlic, ginger, and star anise along with the main ingredients: white (rather than brown) vinegar; vegetable oil infused with sesame seeds; sugar; salt; pepper; chili flakes, and optionally MSG (monosodium glutamate).

Furthermore, unlike these ‘Western’ varieties of mustard – where sugar may be added at any stage during production – this variety adds sweetness primarily by adding certain vegetables like onions during its preparation process rather than through added sugar alone.

What are Some Mustard Seed Substitutes for Pickles?

When it comes to making pickles, the most important ingredient is obviously the brine solution. Typically, this brining solution consists of water, vinegar, spices, and salt — but one common flavor enhancer that many recipes call for is a mustard seed. There are some viable alternatives you can use if you don’t have access to a mustard seed.

One such alternative would be celery seed. Not only does celery seed offer a similar nutty flavor to what you get with mustard seeds in pickling solutions, but it also adds an intriguing aroma and taste to dishes like chicken salad and coleslaws as well as various vegetable based sides like roasted potatoes when used as a topping before baking.

Another potential substitute could be ground coriander powder.

Dill weed might just be good enough if all else fails since its flavors aren’t too different from those offered by mustard seeds (although its intensity may vary depending on how fresh your supply of dried dillweed is).

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q: What is a healthy alternative to mustard?

One option to consider is hummus. Made from chickpeas, tahini, olive oil, and various spices, hummus is a nutritious and delicious alternative condiment that can take the place of traditional mustard. Not only is hummus high in protein, fiber, and micronutrients, but it also provides a satisfying and creamy texture that pairs well with sandwiches, wraps, and burgers.

Q: What is a good substitute for black mustard seeds?

There are a variety of substitutes that can provide similar flavors and textures. One option is brown mustard seeds. You can also try using yellow mustard seeds. Another option is to use a teaspoon of horseradish sauce in place of the mustard seeds.

Q: Which is better- sunflower or mustard?

Some may argue that sunflower seeds are the way to go, given their high levels of vitamin E and antioxidants. Others may favor mustard, noting its natural anti-inflammatory properties and ability to regulate blood glucose levels. Ultimately, the choice between these two popular options comes down to personal preference and intended use.

Q: What do Indians call black mustard seeds in India?

Black mustard seeds, also known as Sarson or Rai, play a crucial role in Indian cuisine.

Bottom Line:

All in all, mustard seed is a highly versatile ingredient that can be used to add flavor to many dishes. It is an excellent nutritional and healthy alternative to traditional spices and herbs and can be substituted with a variety of other ingredients to create unique flavor profiles. It’s important to remember though when substituting mustard seed for different applications, that certain substitutes for mustard seeds best lend themselves to certain applications such as pickling or dry rubs. Additionally, please remember that using alternatives such as ground mustard powder or cumin will have their own unique characteristics so make sure to adjust amounts accordingly.

Ultimately, the best substitute for mustard seeds depends entirely on the dish you are creating so some experimentation may be necessary until you find what works for your taste.

Read Also:

About Author

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

DMCA.com Protection Status

Win one of the 20 coolest kitchen gadgets!

Image of Chefd giveaway Nessie Ladle.

Surprises every month. The fun twist is that you can choose your own in the next step.


Chefd subscribers - contest