10 Best Rum Extract Substitutes to Use in Any Recipe

Rum Extract Substitutes to Use in Any Recipe
19 min reading time

Rum extract is a popular ingredient that adds flavor to many recipes, from chocolate-brownies to cakes and even savory sauces. However, sometimes, it can be challenging to find the right rum extract for your dish or you might want something with less alcohol content. If this is the case then don’t stress! In this post we will discuss 10 great rum extract substitutes so you can enjoy all of your favorite recipes without having to go searching for an elusive bottle of spirits.

Read on and learn how these ingredients add fantastic flavor while still keeping your dishes balanced just as deliciously as real rum does!

What is Rum Extract?

Rum extract is a flavor enhancer made from fermented and distilled molasses (a natural by-product of the sugar refining process) that has been aged in oak casks. It is used in many different types of recipes, ranging from baking to cocktails. Traditionally, rum extract has been used as an ingredient for flavoring baked goods like cakes and cookies, but it has also found its way into adult beverages such as rum punches and exotic cocktails. It can be added to sauces or marinades to give them an extra depth of flavor as well.

Rum extracts come in varying strengths which vary based on the amount of dilution that occurred during preparation; these ranges range from light (25% ABV) all the way up to heavy (100% ABV).

The flavors in this type of extract come from distilled spirits made with fermented molasses and aged in oak barrels for several months. The spirit is then combined with water before being mixed with natural flavors like vanilla, almond, nutmeg and more before being concentrated into an extremely potent form known as extract. The final product contains no added sugar or alcohol but still packs an intense punch when used correctly – just remember that a little goes a long way!

Different Types of Rum Extract

Rum extract is one of the most versatile extracts available, with a wide range of rich and complex flavors. There are many different types of rum extract on the market today, each offering its own unique taste profile. The four main types are light-bodied rums, dark-bodied rums, spiced rums and flavored rums.

Light-bodied rum extract is made from distilled molasses and has an earthy, slightly sweet flavor. It pairs well with citrus fruits like lime or orange in cocktails or other beverages.

Darker bodied rum has a deeper flavor with notes of caramel or toffee that pair well with desserts such as ice cream or flans and can be used to enrich sauces for meats like pork or beef. Popular brands producing dark rum extracts include Pusser’s Navy Rum Liqueur Extract and Don Q Oak Barrel Spiced Air Aged Reserve Liquor Extracts.

Spiced rums feature Caribbean spices such as nutmeg, cinnamon, cloves, ginger root and even red pepper flakes to create a robust flavor profile blending the sweetness of molasses with warm spices making them perfect for baking recipes like holiday cakes or cookies as well as refreshing drinks like hot cocoa topped off with a shot of spiced rum extract!

Flavored rums offer their own unique qualities bringing out tropical flavors that uplift various decadent dishes including Key Lime Pie (Graffiti Lemon Pie), Coconut Meringue Cake (Beach Bum Coconut),Banana Cream Pie(Maituiz Banana) Martina’s Strawberry Daiquiri Mojito Mint Julep (Kiwi Twist).

What Does Rum Extract Taste Like?

Rum extract is a concentrated flavoring of the fermented and distilled beverage known as rum. It has an intense, sweet, woody flavor that is instantly recognizable because of its intense aroma. Its taste will vary depending on the type of rum used – light rums will have more sweetness while darker varieties will have more depth and complexity to their flavor profile.

Some notes you might find in the taste include caramelized sugar, dried fruits such as raisins or prunes, and smoky oak flavors from aging in wooden barrels. Overall it has much more nuanced flavor than typical liquors or spirits due to its aging process.

Why Look for Rum Extract Substitutes?

Rum extract is a concentrated form of rum that’s typically used to flavor desserts, such as cakes and cookies. While it adds an unmistakable taste to your culinary creations, there are several reasons why you may want to find a substitute for rum extract.

First of all, rum extract can be difficult to find in certain areas depending on the availability in stores or online. Additionally, if you prefer not to use alcohol when cooking or baking, then finding substitutes would be the best way for you to achieve the same desired result without incorporating any alcohol into your dishes.

Fortunately, there is no shortage of alternatives that will mimic the flavors one would expect from using traditional rum extract as part of their recipes. For example, almond extract combined with vanilla extract can serve as a great replacement for rum.

So, read on and learn about different Rum Extract Substitutes to Use in any recipe.

How to Choose the Best Rum Extract Substitute?

When it comes to choosing the best rum extract substitute, there are several factors that should be taken into consideration. The first factor is your personal preference. Do you prefer a sweeter flavor or one that is more robust and smoky? Some substitutes can provide sweetness without too much of the strong alcohol taste of traditional dark rum flavoring extract while others might offer more body and complexity.

Another factor to consider when selecting the best rum extract substitute is whether you will be using it in cooking or baking recipes. If you’re preparing savory dishes like stews and roasts which call for browning ingredients then a darker flavored syrup such as molasses may be preferable. On the other hand if you’re creating pastry-style treats then an amber colored syrup such as maple may bring out all the desired characteristics needed to create just the right balance between sweetness and texture.

Finally, another important point to remember when deciding upon an appropriate substitute for rum extract is that not all extracts are created equal so you should always read labels carefully in order to make sure what type of alcohol is contained within each bottle (i.e., light versus dark).

Best Rum Extract Substitutes

For many of us, rum extract is a key ingredient when we’re looking to add a little extra flavor to baking recipes or cocktails. But what happens when you’re fresh out of rum extract? Fear not! There are plenty of great substitutes that can be used in its place. Get creative and experiment with different flavor combinations to find your perfect rum extract substitute.

1. Rum

Rum is a type of distilled alcoholic beverage made from fermented sugarcane, molasses, or other agricultural crop such as grapes. Rum is indeed a suitable substitute for rum extract in baking and cooking. In fact, it can enhance the flavor of recipes quite nicely!

When using rum as an extract substitute, you’ll find that you don’t need to use as much because it has a more concentrated flavor than extracts do. It is also important to consider the type of rum used – light or dark – depending on what kind of recipe you are preparing. Light rums tend to be slightly sweeter and milder whereas dark rums contain more robust flavors such as molasses, brown sugar, vanilla, raisins, buttery notes etc., making them perfect for heavier desserts like chocolate cakes or crumbles.

In order to use rum effectively as an extract substitute in baking or cooking recipes we recommend adding 1-2 tablespoons per cup of liquid (milk/fruit juice) called for in the recipe or add ½ teaspoon per tablespoon called for in the original ingredients list if replacing extracts like vanilla.

To replace stronger flavored extracts like almond try adding 3-4 tablespoons per cup liquid called for in your recipe along with adding additional spices such as nutmeg and cinnamon if desired; while apricot brandy would work well too at about 1 teaspoon per tablespoon measure required from original ingredients list (again adjust accordingly based upon personal preference).

2. Vanilla Extract

Vanilla Extract is a great substitute for Rum Extract due to its flavor profile. While both extracts are derived from the same species of plant, vanilla extract is made from only the seed pod, or bean, of the vanilla vine while rum extract is made from its fruits. This means that rum extract can have a subtle sweetness that could potentially alter recipes when used as a substitute for vanilla extract.

Vanilla extract’s flavor profile consists primarily of vanillin and other aromatic compounds which contribute to its sweet scent and taste. It’s important to note that artificial flavors also play an important role in most commercial vanilla extracts; however this is done with natural flavors derived from various sources such as clove oil, cinnamon bark oil, or citrus oils.

When comparing these two types of extracts we find several key benefits when using Vanilla Extract over Rum Extract – first off since they have different concentrations they will affect your recipe differently; secondly Vanilla doesn’t contain ethyl alcohol so it won’t leave behind any boozy aftertaste; finally because it contains no added sugar like what you would find in rum.

3. Bourbon

Bourbon is an incredibly versatile liquor that can be used as a substitute for rum extract in many recipes, cocktails, and dishes. There are two main reasons why the use of bourbon as a rum extract replacement makes perfect sense; taste and cost.

Taste wise, bourbon and rum have similar flavor profiles with the primary difference being that rye whiskey is aged much longer than most rums, giving it a richer complexity that’s much closer to a good quality dark Caribbean Rum. The flavors imparted by bourbon are more wood-forward while those from rum are generally sweeter and spicier due to its shorter aging process. As such, when substituting bourbon for rum extract in any recipe or drink, you’ll likely notice a deeper woody flavor with just the right touch of sweetness coming through without having to add any additional sweeteners like granulated sugar or honey!

In terms of cost benefit analysis swapping out your regular bottle of run extract for one made from Bourbon could end up saving you some money over time. Plus because there’s so many different varieties of Bourbon available on the market today ranging from light/milder blends all the way up to intense high proof offerings – you’re sure to find something perfectly suited both your palate & pocketbook.

4. Coffee Extract

Coffee extract is made from freshly brewed espresso, which gives it a concentrated and intense flavor. It can be used to add depth of flavor without adding the distinctive taste of alcohol that comes with using traditional rum extract. Additionally, unlike many liqueurs or spirits, coffee extract does not contain any alcoholic content.

The primary advantage of using coffee extract instead of rum is that it eliminates the risk of alcohol consumption when ingested. This makes it an ideal ingredient for those who are looking for non-alcoholic alternatives when baking cakes or making desserts for children or other guests who do not wish to consume alcohol. Its powerful aroma also provides unparalleled depth and complex flavor components that cannot be found in pure rum extracts while still providing similar sweetness levels and intensities.

Coffee extracts are also generally more affordable than their traditional counterparts because they use pre-brewed espresso. Furthermore, since there is no actual alcoholic content present in this product, there won’t be any worries about licensing fees associated with buying store-bought products either!

5. Tequila

Tequila has been used as a substitute for rum extract in baking or cocktails for a number of reasons. The most important factor is that tequila provides an additional flavor profile to an otherwise bland dish. It also adds a unique, spicy, and smoky kick that can’t be easily replicated with any other ingredient.

When using tequila as a rum extract substitute, it’s best to use blanco or reposado varieties rather than aged ones; these are smoother and bring out the flavor of the tequila more effectively without being too intense. Tequila is also much lighter than traditional rum extract and doesn’t have quite as much sugar content so modifications may need to be made if using it directly instead of adding sugar elsewhere (such as adding molasses).

To adjust for sweetness, try substituting some orange liqueur or triple sec (about 1 part orange liqueur per 2 parts tequila). Additionally, you may need to reduce your recipe’s liquid by about 25% due to the added moisture from tequila itself. These adjustments may vary depending on what type of recipe is used though!

6. Cachaca

Cachaça, also known as Brazilian rum, is a distilled alcoholic beverage made from fermented sugarcane juice. As an extract substitute, Cachaça offers some advantages over traditional rum extracts due to its unique flavor profile.

First off, it is much smoother than rum extract with a more complex flavor that lends itself well to a variety of drinks and dishes. One of the main differences between Cachaça and rum extract are the notes of floral and grassy undertones that give this spirit its distinct taste. In particular, Cachaça has a distinct sweetness that makes it stand apart from other rums or spirits used for homemade mixers or tinctures.

Not only does it have these unique flavors but it also adds complexity into any recipe you use it for due to its slightly higher alcohol content (38-48% ABV). On top of these qualities, cachaça can also be aged in wood barrels resulting in different varieties such as Silver (unaged), Amber (aged 1-3 years) or Gold (aged 3+ years).

7. Cognac

Cognac has a unique sweet and fruity taste that comes from its aging process where it is aged in French oak barrels, giving it hints of oak-like flavors. When incorporated into a recipe, the cognac adds depth to the overall flavor profile without overpowering other ingredients. Even small amounts can be very impactful against more robust flavors like extracts and spices.

Cognac has a distinct flavor profile that comes from the double distillation process it undergoes. This distinctive character is derived from the combination of both copper pot stills (Alembic) and column stills (Charentais): this method of double distillation produces an intense aroma and high alcohol content (around 40%). During aging, Cognacs absorb oak tannins which give them their characteristic colors: ranging from golden yellow or pale amber hues to dark mahogany or deep brown shades.

When using Cognac as an alternative to traditional rum extract in culinary recipes you will need approximately half the amount required by rum since its alcohol concentration level is much higher than most liqueurs. Its rich flavour also compliments many sweet dishes making it perfect when added to cakes, cookies or ice cream toppings.

8. Orange Liqueur

Orange liqueur is an excellent substitute for rum extract in baking and cooking. It has a sweet, citrusy flavor that adds a unique depth to dishes. This type of liqueur is made from oranges, sugar, spices, and alcohol such as brandy or vodka. The sweetness of the orange combines with the alcohol to create a complex flavor that works well in recipes calling for rum extract.

The taste can vary depending on the ingredients used but will generally be slightly bitter and sweet at the same time; this makes it great for adding complexity to recipes calling for just one type of extract like vanilla or almond extract. Orange liqueur can also be used to add punchiness and brightness in cocktails like Margaritas or mimosas, giving them extra zing without having to use any rum itself!

When substituting orange liqueur for rum extract in baking recipes like cakes or brownies, it’s best to start by using half as much as the recipe calls for (i.e., if your recipe requires 2 teaspoons of rum extract you should use 1 teaspoon of orange liqueur). This will help keep your dish balanced while still allowing you to experience all its wonderful flavors!

9. Coconut Rum

Coconut rum is an increasingly popular alternative to traditional rum extracts. In fact, some of the big brands are even starting to switch from using synthetic extracts to natural coconut rum, as they find it has a more authentic flavor profile. Coconut rum is made from a combination of molasses and three-year-old dark Caribbean rum that has been steeped with freshly grated coconut for several hours.

One of the main advantages to using coconut rum as opposed to standard flavored liqueurs or extract substitutes is that it doesn’t contain any added sugar or alcohol content beyond what’s already present in regular rums. This makes it much friendlier for those watching their calorie intake while also bringing out deeper flavor notes than traditional flavoring ingredients like syrups or artificial extracts can provide.

Due to its lack of artificial additives like coloring agents found in other tricksy drinks like Smirnoff Ices, Coconut Rum mixes better when combined with juices and other mixers due its smooth consistency without compromising on taste quality or aroma either – you won’t be left disappointed!

10. Almond Extract

Almond extract is an incredibly versatile ingredient that can be used as an alternative to many different types of extracts, including rum extract. There are a few reasons why almond extract may be preferable over rum extract in certain recipes or baking projects.

First and foremost, it’s important to note that almond extract has a more intense flavor than rum extract. Because of this, it can add deeper notes of flavor to dishes when used as a substitute for its counterparts. In addition, the flavor profile is not overly sweet which helps avoid having too heavy of a hand when using almond extract as opposed to some other alternatives like vanilla or banana extracts.

Another benefit associated with using almond extract rather than traditional rum extraction is its health benefits. Almonds are an excellent source of vitamins and minerals including vitamin E and magnesium which help support healthy skin, hair, bones and teeth; plus they contain antioxidants making them great for overall health! almond extracted products achieve their full flavors much faster due to their use of natural oils instead which will significantly reduce preparation time depending on what typeof recipe you’re utilizing them in!

How Much Rum Extract Should be Used?

To determine the amount of rum extract that you should use, it depends on what type of recipe you are making and the desired strength of your final product. Generally, for most baking recipes, one teaspoon of pure rum extract is equivalent to one tablespoon (about 0.5 fluid ounce) of 80-proof rum or dark rum. If a stronger flavor is desired, add an additional 1/4 teaspoon at a time until the desired taste has been achieved.

When using lighter varieties, like spiced rums or white rums that contain lower levels of alcohol (generally 40-50 proof), start by adding only 1/2 teaspoon and adjust from there as needed depending on how strong the flavor needs to be in your finished dish. If ingredients other than those containing alcohol are included in your recipe but you would still like a hint or depth added by including an alcoholic flavor component, consider reducing some liquid ingredients and adding slightly more extract than what is called for in the recipe instead.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Can I Use Sherry Instead Of Rum Extract?

While sherry and rum have distinct flavors, sherry can provide a similar depth of flavor that rum extract brings to baked goods. In fact, sherry has been used as a substitute for rum extract in many recipes. It’s important to keep in mind that sherry has a higher alcohol content than rum extract, so it’s recommended to use half the amount of sherry as the recipe calls for extract.

Is Rum Extract Contain Alcohol?

The answer is yes. Rum extract is made by steeping rum in water and allowing the alcohol to evaporate, leaving behind the concentrated flavor of the rum. However, because the process does involve steeping the rum in alcohol — and because some brands may still contain trace amounts — it’s important to be mindful of consumption if you’re avoiding alcohol altogether.

What Is Rum Flavor Made Of?

The key ingredient in rum flavor is the molasses that results from refining sugar cane juice. When combined with yeast and water, molasses undergoes a process of fermentation, which ultimately leads to the creation of rum. During this process, the molasses imparts a rich, dark, and complex flavor to the finished product.

What is the Alcohol Percentage of Rum Extract?

Typically, rum extract contains anywhere from 35% to 50% alcohol by volume (ABV).

What Is The Best Non-alcoholic Rum Extract Substitute?

One popular choice is using vanilla extract or paste, which adds a sweet, subtle flavor that pairs well with many desserts and beverages. Another option is using coconut extract or flavoring, for a tropical twist in recipes like piña coladas or coconut macaroons.

Bottom Line:

Rum extract tastes like a popular Caribbean beverage but still packs punch. Even without rum extract, home chefs can still make tasty food as there are several alternatives that help bring out the flavors and aromas of many recipes. Whether you choose vanilla extract, bourbon, coffee extract, tequila or any other substitute, always use your nose and taste buds to choose the best one. If possible, try them all and see which works for you! Ultimately, depending on what dish you’re making and what flavors you want to bring out in it, a good rum extract substitute can truly elevate your next meal.

So don’t be afraid to experiment; there’s no bad outcome when trying new ingredients! And whether you successfully find an appropriate rum extract alternative or not, remember that creating something special with whatever ingredients are available is often its own reward.

Read Also:

About Author


  • Danielle Weston

    Vanilla extract over everything! 🙌

  • Lydia Edwards

    Bourbon as a substitute for rum extract? Now that’s something I’ve got to try!

  • Kiera West

    Coconut rum? Sign me up! 🥥🍹

  • Eleanor Fraser

    I’ve always used McCormick’s Imitation Rum Extract. Works like a charm! 👌

  • Tilly Harris

    I’m a bit skeptical about using tequila as a substitute, won’t it drastically change the flavor profile?

  • Alisha Owens

    As someone who’s been baking for over 15 years, I’ve tried a variety of substitutes when I run out of rum extract. In my experience, nothing beats the real deal. However, I understand that not everyone has access to high-quality rum extract or prefers not to use alcohol in their cooking. In those cases, vanilla extract can be a decent alternative as it adds a pleasant sweetness to the dish. For those looking for a non-alcoholic substitute, apple juice mixed with a touch of almond extract or cinnamon can mimic some of the complex flavors in rum.

  • Aaliyah Roberts

    Almond extract? Really? 🤔

  • Yasmin Murphy

    Cognac seems like an interesting choice. Has anyone tried it?

  • Victoria Cameron

    Why would anyone substitute rum extract? Nothing else quite captures that unique flavor!

  • Megan Lloyd

    I love adding a splash of bourbon instead of rum extract. It gives my desserts a rich, smoky undertone. Highly recommend trying it out!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

DMCA.com Protection Status

Win one of the 20 coolest kitchen gadgets!

Image of Chefd giveaway Nessie Ladle.

Surprises every month. The fun twist is that you can choose your own in the next step.


Chefd subscribers - contest