Best Potatoes for Mashing: Top Potatoes to Use for the Creamiest Results

Best Potatoes for Mashing
10 min reading time

If you’re like us, mashed potatoes are a kitchen must-have. Whether you’re serving them as comfort food on chilly nights or whipping up creamy sides to classic entrees, there’s just something special and comforting about properly prepared mashed potatoes. But not all potatoes can give your mash those perfect, buttery results! Knowing which are the best potatoes for mashing will ensure that every meal is one to savor and remember.

In this blog post, we’ll explore the various types of potatoes available for mashing together with some top tips to get the tastiest results!

Which are the Best Potatoes For Mashing?

When it comes to making mashed potatoes, not all potatoes are created equal in terms of texture, taste, and consistency. Some are better suited for boiling, baking, and frying. If you want a smooth and creamy mash, you will need to choose the right potatoes. The best potatoes for mashing are the starchy varieties such as russets, Yukon Gold, Desiree, Maris Piper, and fingerling potatoes. These potatoes absorb butter and milk well and have a fluffy texture that is perfect for mashing.

1. Russet Potatoes

Raw Brown Organic Russet Potatoes

Russet potatoes are often cited as the best for making mashed potatoes because of their high starch content. This makes them perfect for creating a creamy, fluffy texture when cooked and mashed.

Unlike other potato varieties, such as red-skinned potatoes which contain more water, russets have thicker skins that reduce moisture loss during cooking. These thick skins also help eliminate excess peeling, so you can save time and energy in the kitchen! Additionally, the higher starch content helps hold together when mashing them and prevents them from becoming gummy or lumpy.

Another reason why russet potatoes are ideal for making mashed potatoes is due to their flavor profile. Russets have a robust taste with an earthy nuttiness that stands up well to seasoning and spices used in mashed potato recipes like garlic, herbs, or Parmesan cheese – allowing all these flavors to come through beautifully!

Finally, russets don’t lose their shape even after boiling for extended periods of time – this means they won’t be too mushy but will still have a nice bite when combined with other ingredients like butter and cream cheese in your finished dish!

2. Yukon Gold Potatoes

Closeup shot of fresh ripe yukon gold potatoes isolated on white background

Yukon Gold potatoes are widely regarded as the best type of potato for making mashed potatoes. They have a higher-than-average starch content and a unique cohesiveness that makes them easy to mash without becoming too watery or dense. The natural buttery flavor also adds extra richness and smoothness to your mashed potatoes, so you won’t need as much butter or cream.

The creamy, fluffy texture is one of the main reasons why Yukon Gold has become so popular for making mashed potatoes. It’s because their medium-starch content prevents them from getting too mushy or turning into a gummy mess when boiled and mashed together with other ingredients like milk, butter, chives, garlic powder, cheese, etc. Additionally, they contain significant levels of antioxidant pigments which contribute positively to their flavor and nutritional values such as vitamin C and antioxidants which can help reduce risk factors for certain diseases.

Another benefit of using Yukon Gold potatoes is that you don’t need peeling before boiling them! Since they’re in general quite thinner skinned than other varieties of potato so all you have to do is give them a good wash and then pop them directly into the pot – this saves time preparing your dish and helps ensure all the important nutritious components stay intact during the cooking process.

3. Desiree Potatoes

desiree potatoes - one of the best potatoes for mashing

No other potato can compare to Desiree potatoes when it comes to making mashed potatoes. Their thick, firm flesh makes them an ideal choice for mashing up into a smooth and creamy side dish. Not only are they easy to mash due to their texture but their mild flavor also allows the seasonings you use to shine through even more.

Desiree potatoes have a lower starch content than other potato varieties like Russet or Idaho. This is because of how quickly they cook with steam, meaning that the starches don’t degrade and break down as much during the cooking process so your finished mashed potatoes stay light and fluffy instead of dense or gummy. You won’t even need any extra butter or milk when using these kinds of potatoes!

Another great thing about Desiree’s is their vibrant red skin—they look beautiful on the plate so your meals can always look picture-perfect! Plus, since they’re already peeled you’ll save time prepping them for recipes like mashed potatoes rather than having to manually peel each one yourself every time you want a meal ready in minutes.

In summary, Desiree’s is definitely the best variety of potatoes when it comes to making creamy, delicious mashed spuds!

4. Maris Piper

raw maris piper potatoes

Maris Piper potatoes are widely regarded as one of the best types for making mashed potatoes. This is largely due to their combination of softness and floury texture, allowing them to break down easily when cooked and create a creamy yet fluffy mash. Maris Pipers have an ideal balance between dry matter content and starch levels, giving them a natural ability to absorb more cream or butter than other spuds – so not only will your mash look great but it’ll also taste amazing! The waxy outer skin helps hold onto the potato pieces during cooking, further enabling the fluffy texture and keeping that fresh-cooked flavor locked in.

Their versatility makes them suitable for all kinds of mashing methods too; steaming, boiling, or microwaving can be used depending on what you prefer with excellent results each time. And if you’re looking for added color or crunch there’s nothing stopping you from adding roasted vegetables like parsnips or carrots either! For these reasons, Maris Pipers offer consistency when it comes to creating delicious mashed potatoes – every time they come out perfect!

5. Fingerling Potatoes

non gmo fingerling potatoes

Fingerling potatoes are a type of small- to medium-sized potato that is one of the best potatoes for mashing. They come in several unique varieties, including Yellow Finn, Red Bliss, Russian Banana, and Gold Rush. These potatoes also have an ultra-creamy texture when cooked which makes them perfect for mashing.

Fingerling potatoes contain less starch than other varieties of potatoes so they can make incredibly creamy mashed potatoes without having to add extra fat or cream. The starch content also helps the potato retain its shape even when they are mashed, giving you beautiful pieces of fluffed potato suspended in a smooth and creamy mixture – not lumpy mashed potatoes!

Additionally, these small tubers cook faster than larger varieties since their surface area-to-volume ratio is greater. That means less time spent boiling and mashing your way through mountains of spuds. Plus there’s no peeling required as the thin skin adds flavor and nutrition so you don’t need to waste time taking it off either!

Altogether this makes fingerling potatoes an ideal choice for making delicious mashed potatoes quickly with all the right texture and flavor!

How Long to Make Mashed Potatoes with Each Type Of Potatoes?

Potato TypeCooking Time for Mashed Potatoes
Russet Potatoes20-25 minutes
Yukon Gold20-25 minutes
Desiree20-25 minutes
Maris Piper20-25 minutes
Fingerling15-20 minutes
Cooking Time for Mashed Potatoes for Each Type

Please note that cooking times may vary slightly depending on the size of the potato pieces and the method of cooking (boiling, steaming, or microwaving). Make sure to cook the potatoes until they are easily pierced with a fork for the best mashing results.

Which are the Best Tools for Making Mashed Potatoes?

When it comes to making the perfect mashed potatoes, having the right tools can make all the difference. A potato peeler is essential for easily removing the skin from your potatoes, while a sharp knife or a potato cutter helps in cutting them into uniform pieces for even cooking. To cook the potatoes, a large pot with a lid and a steamer basket or insert is ideal. Once the potatoes are cooked, a potato masher or a potato ricer is crucial for achieving a smooth and fluffy texture.

If you prefer a creamier consistency, an electric hand mixer or a stand mixer with a paddle attachment can also be used. Finally, a sturdy wooden spoon or silicone spatula is handy for incorporating butter, cream, or other ingredients to achieve the desired flavor and texture of your mashed potatoes. With these tools in your kitchen arsenal, you’ll be well-equipped to make delicious, restaurant-quality mashed potatoes at home.

How to Make Mashed Potatoes? (Step-by-Step Instructions?

Making mashed potatoes is one of the simplest yet most delicious side dishes. With just a few ingredients and quick steps, you can whip up this creamy classic in no time! Here’s how to do it:

  • Step 1 – Gather your ingredients. You’ll need about 4-5 medium Russet potatoes (1-1/2 lb.), 3 tablespoons butter, ½ cup milk, salt and pepper to taste. Optional extras include garlic powder or minced onion for added flavor!
  • Step 2 – Wash and peel the potatoes then cut them into cubes. Place the cubes in a large pot with enough water to cover them, bring to a boil then reduce heat so that they can simmer for 15 minutes (until tender) stirring occasionally.
  • Step 3 – Once cooked, take off heat and use a potato masher or electric mixer on low speed until desired consistency is achieved adding butter (or margarine), milk, salt & pepper as you mash/mix until your perfect mashed potatoes are ready! For added flavor, you can incorporate garlic powder or minced onions at this point if desired. Serve warm with gravy or condiments of your choice for an absolutely scrumptious dish everyone will love!

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Why do some potato varieties make fluffier mashed potatoes than others?

The texture of mashed potatoes depends on the starch content of the potato variety. High-starch potatoes like Russets and Maris Pipers result in fluffier and lighter mashed potatoes, while low-starch varieties like fingerlings yield a creamier, denser texture.

Can I mix different varieties of potatoes to create a unique mashed potato dish?

Absolutely! Combining different potato types can result in a unique blend of flavors and textures. For instance, mixing a high-starch potato like Russet with a waxy potato like Yukon Gold can deliver a perfect balance of fluffiness and creaminess.

What are some creative flavor additions for mashed potatoes beyond the standard butter and cream?

To elevate your mashed potatoes, consider adding ingredients like roasted garlic, caramelized onions, fresh herbs (such as chives or rosemary), grated cheese, horseradish, or even bacon bits. Experimenting with various flavors can lead to exciting and delicious results.

How can I make vegan or dairy-free mashed potatoes without compromising on taste and texture?

You can substitute traditional dairy ingredients with alternatives like olive oil, vegan butter, or coconut cream. Additionally, using vegetable broth or unsweetened almond milk can provide creaminess without dairy. Don’t forget to season well with salt and pepper for maximum flavor.

Bottom Line

In the end, when you’re ready to mash up some potatoes, it’s essential to choose the right potato variety. Different potatoes give different textures and tastes and depending on what you are making from mashed potatoes, some may be better than others. Each of these potatoes will provide great results if cooked correctly and result in delicious mashed potatoes sure to please everyone around your dinner table. So grab those spuds, experiment with the different varieties of potatoes out there, and get to mashing!

Read Also:

About Author

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked * Protection Status

Win one of the 20 coolest kitchen gadgets!

Image of Chefd giveaway Nessie Ladle.

Surprises every month. The fun twist is that you can choose your own in the next step.


Chefd subscribers - contest